[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Why futures truth doesn't care about stealing your system



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links

Every now and then someone says MatLab is good for financial programmers.
Look at the prices below from the MathWorks web site.  They make
TradeStation at $2500 look cheep. Just the C++ Math Library is $900! Their
"Real-Time Workshop" is $21,870!! The MatLab stuff is for people with more
money than brains.


Select  Product Suite  Includes  Price (US$)

  C/C++ Application Development Suite MATLAB, MATLAB Compiler, MATLAB C/C++
Math Library, MATLAB C/C++ Graphics Library  $3,772.00

  Communication Master Suite MATLAB, Simulink, Signal Processing Tlbx, DSP
Blockset, Communications Tlbx, Communications Blockset, Stateflow, Stateflow
Coder, Real-Time Workshop  $18,990.00

  Communications System Design Suite MATLAB, Simulink, Signal Processing
Tlbx, DSP Blockset, Communications Tlbx, Communications Blockset, Stateflow
$9,720.00

  Control Design Master Suite MATLAB, Simulink, Stateflow, Control System
Tlbx, Nonlinear Control Design Blkst, Signal Processing Tlbx, Optimization
Tlbx, System Identification Tlbx, Real-Time Workshop, Stateflow Coder,
Fixed-Point Blockset  $21,870.00

  Control Design Suite MATLAB, Simulink, Stateflow, Control System Tlbx
$7,650.00

  DSP Design Suite MATLAB, Simulink, Signal Processing Tlbx, DSP Blockset
$5,760.00

  DSP Rapid Prototyping Suite MATLAB, Simulink, Signal Processing Tlbx, DSP
Blockset, Real-Time Workshop  $12,510.00

  Data Analysis Suite MATLAB, Signal Processing Tlbx, Optimization Tlbx,
Statistics Tlbx, Wavelet Tlbx, Neural Network Tlbx  $5,310.00

  Image Processing Suite MATLAB, Image Processing Tlbx, Signal Processing
Tlbx  $3,150.00

  Test and Measurement Suite MATLAB, Data Acquisition Tlbx, Instrument
Control, Signal Processing Tlbx  $3,690.00

Product Suites requiring MATLAB
Select  Product Suite  Includes  Price (US$)
  Advanced Analysis Suite Optimization Tlbx, Statistics Tlbx, Wavelet Tlbx,
Neural Network Tlbx  $2,970.00

  Advanced Control Design Suite Nonlinear Control Design Blkst, Signal
Processing Tlbx, Optimization Tlbx, System Identification Tlbx  $3,150.00

  Advanced Financial Add-on Suite Database Toolbox, Financial Time Series,
GARCH Tlbx, Financial Derivatives Tlbx  $3,240.00

  C/C++ Compiler Suite MATLAB Compiler, MATLAB C/C++ Math Library, MATLAB
C/C++ Graphics Library  $1,890.00

  Control Design Code Generation Suite Real-Time Workshop, Fixed-Point
Blockset, Stateflow Coder  $11,070.00

  Financial Suite Optimization Tlbx, Statistics Tlbx, Excel Link, Financial
Tlbx  $2,340.00

  Test and Measurement Add On Suite Data Acquisition Tlbx, Instrument
Control  $1,200.00

Select  Product  Price (US$)
  MATLAB $1,900.00      MATLAB Compiler $900.00
   MATLAB C/C++ Math Library $900.00      MATLAB C/C++ Graphics Library
$900.00

  MATLAB Report Generator $600.00      Matrix VB $1,000.00
Math and Analysis Toolboxes
  Optimization Tlbx $900.00     Statistics Tlbx $600.00
  Neural Network Tlbx $900.00     Symbolic Math Tlbx $600.00
   Extended Symbolic Math Tlbx $900.00     Partial Differential Equations
$900.00
  Mapping Tlbx $900.00     Spline Tlbx $400.00

Data Acquisition and Import Toolboxes
   Data Acquisition Tlbx $900.00      Instrument Control $600.00
   Database Toolbox $1,000.00      Excel Link $200.00

Signal and Image Processing Toolboxes
  Signal Processing Tlbx $700.00      Image Processing Tlbx $900.00
   Communications Tlbx $600.00      System Identification Tlbx $900.00
   Wavelet Tlbx $900.00      Filter Design Tlbx $1,000.00
   Developer's Kit for TI DSP $1,000.00      Motorola DSP Developers Kit
$600.00

Control Design and Analysis Toolboxes
  Control System Tlbx $1,000.00     Fuzzy Logic Tlbx $900.00
   Robust Control Tlbx $900.00      MU-Analysis and Synthesis Tlbx $900.00
   LMI Control Tlbx $900.00      Model Predictive Control Tlbx $900.00

Finance and Economics Toolboxes
   Financial Tlbx $900.00      Financial Time Series $600.00
   GARCH Tlbx $1,000.00     Datafeed Tlbx $1,000.00
   Financial Derivatives Tlbx $1,000.00

Simulink
  Simulink $2,800.00     Simulink Performance Tools $500.00
   Stateflow $2,800.00      Stateflow Coder $2,800.00
   Real-Time Workshop $7,500.00      RTW ADA Coder $5,000.00
   RTW Embedded Coder $5,000.00      Real-Time Windows Target $2,000.00
   xPC Target $4,000.00      xPC Target Embedded Option $4,000.00
   Simulink Report Generator $1,400.00      Requirements Management Tool
$600.00

Simulink Blocksets
   DSP Blockset $1,000.00      Fixed-Point Blockset $2,000.00
   Power System Blockset $2,000.00      Dials & Gauges Blockset $700.00
   Communications Blockset $1,000.00      CDMA Reference Blockset $2,000.00
   Nonlinear Control Design Blkst $1,000.00


----- Original Message -----
From: "Brian" <blink64@xxxxxxxx>
To: "List, Omega" <omega-list@xxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: Saturday, March 31, 2001 11:58 PM
Subject: FW: Why futures truth doesn't care about stealing your system


>
> For all the power users out there.
>
> http://www.mathworks.com/products/mathlibrary/
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Brian [mailto:blink64@xxxxxxxx]
> Sent: Saturday, March 31, 2001 8:52 PM
> To: List, Omega
> Subject: RE: Why futures truth doesn't care about stealing your system
>
>
> " basically you have to differentiate between a
> > - trading platform and
> > - research platform"
>
> Agreed.  TS wasn't designed to be pure math research platform.  You can't
> criticize TS for being an inadequate research platform because it wasn't
> designed to be Mathlab.  I feel that for the price, it does a lot and
offers
> most people an endless amount of flexibilty.  You can't backtest in
Mathlab
> can you?  You can't auto monitor positions in ML right?  TS was designed
to
> be a trading platform that does all the nec things fairly well for a
> reasonable price.  Most people wouldn't know what to do with MathLab.
>
> How would you port MatLab and Mathcad to TS?  Develop an api interface
> between TS and ML?
>
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: Bilo Selhi [mailto:citadel@xxxxxxxxxxxx]
> > Sent: Saturday, March 31, 2001 5:41 PM
> > To: orcas@xxxxxxxx; List, Omega
> > Subject: Re: Why futures truth doesn't care about stealing your system
> >
> >
> > Matlab and MathCad are serious math and engineering
> > apps. you can't buy an ocx that can replace those.
> > matlab language is similar to C but specialized.
> > you can't compare C dev tool with math platforms.
> > Matlab or Splus are interactive math platforms. you use it
> > for research. once you are done with your research then
> > you can hard code your code in C for efficiency.
> > basically you have to differentiate between a
> > - trading platform and
> > - research platform
> > tradestation is mix of both but it's no match to number crunching
> > ability of Matlab or Splus. but as same time those are
> > not adapted to trading.
> > if you put both together you get the best of both worlds.
> > and my personal experience is that tradestation is on it's way
> > of  becoming a decent trading platform on which you can depend.
> > although it doing it very slow. the drawback there is that
> > tradestation is not yet mission critical application and not yet
> > fast and dependable enough to be used for high end heavy load
> > professional trading. it's getting there but slow.
> > bilo.
> > ps. i Trad was smart enough they port TS both to matlab and mathcad
> > and i am sure they'd start picking up some institutional and
professional
> > clientele
> > FYU, both Matlab and Splus are ported to Bloomberg. this
> > combination is the
> > standard research platform for top large research and trading
> > firms and high
> > tech
> > financial engineering firms. for them tradestation is somewhat an
> > interesting toy...
> >
> > ----- Original Message -----
> > From: "Brian" <blink64@xxxxxxxx>
> > To: "List, Omega" <omega-list@xxxxxxxxxx>
> > Sent: Saturday, March 31, 2001 4:16 PM
> > Subject: RE: Why futures truth doesn't care about stealing your system
> >
> >
> > > "TS is a toy.  We need serious programs that are capable
> > > of serious number crunching like what MatLab and MathCad can do."
> > >
> > > Buy a C++ OCX that does everything (or at least most) MatLab and
MathCad
> > can
> > > do, insert it into your DLL that TS calls and what do you have?
> >  You have
> > a
> > > trading platform that really can do it all.  I think C++ is just as
> > flexible
> > > if not more than MatLab or MathCad and it's better becaue it
> > can work real
> > > time.  Aren't MathCad and ML both stand alone apps?  Learning C++ (or
> > > powerbasic!) is about as complicated as learning to use MatLab
> > or MathCad
> > > effectively.  I like that approach better over something like
> > MathCad and
> > > that's why I'd still choose Tradestation.
> > >
> > > > -----Original Message-----
> > > > From: Mark Cerar [mailto:marQc@xxxxxxxxxxx]
> > > > Sent: Friday, March 30, 2001 8:38 PM
> > > > To: Lawrence Chan; omega-list@xxxxxxxxxx
> > > > Subject: RE: Why futures truth doesn't care about stealing your
system
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > Bang on Lawrence!  TS is a toy.  We need serious programs that are
> > capable
> > > > of serious number crunching like what MatLab and MathCad can do.
> > > > Engineers,
> > > > statisticians and scientists would not use crap like TS and in
> > > > many ways the
> > > > demands of real-time financial software are even greater than the
more
>
> > > > "static" data they frequently work on.  If OR continues on its
present
> > > > course, TS in all its permutations and combinations will NEVER,
> > > > EVER become
> > > > the de facto trading-software standard of the future.  In fact,
> > > > it's fate is
> > > > being sealed as we speak.  I hope you are all preparing.  The end is
> > nigh.
> > > >
> > > > -----Original Message-----
> > > > From: Lawrence Chan [mailto:stnahc@xxxxxxxx]
> > > > Sent: March 30, 2001 9:50 AM
> > > > To: brian; omega-list@xxxxxxxxxx
> > > > Subject: Re: Why futures truth doesn't care about stealing your
system
> > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > foucs on money management is a waste of time -
> > > > IF the base model does not have the necessary
> > > > "edge".
> > > >
> > > > And in fact, there are new models emerged over the
> > > > past few years not available to the public that
> > > > perform very well during both 1999 and 2000, for 2001
> > > > we have to see.
> > > >
> > > > Excalibur cannot test these new models as the design
> > > > of Excalibur just cannot handle it, period.
> > > >
> > > > The good news is that nor TS can do it at all :)
> > > >
> > > > -Lawrence
> > > > Lawrence Chan                http://www.tickquest.com
> > > > Home of trading tools NeoBreadth and NeoTicker series
> > > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>