[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Re[2]: Which holds best promise?



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links

Hi Mark,

I guess we can agree to disagree on the capabilities of computers.  My firm
belief after working in that industry for 15 years is that computers are
excellent tools, but by no means can they do everything better than a human
can do.

To each his own...

Bob

-----Original Message-----
From: Mark Brown <markbrown@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
To: omega-list@xxxxxxxxxx <omega-list@xxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Wednesday, February 16, 2000 3:09 PM
Subject: Re[2]: Which holds best promise?


>Hello  Bob,
>
>BH> I understand what you are saying.  My point is that a computer can't
>BH> recognize the conditions, only the human eye can.
>
>Wrong  -  if  you  ever watch A&E Investigative reports you would know
>that it has been proven time and again that what the human eye sees is
>in fact a rough guess of what we expect to see! Then in a court of law
>it  has  been  proven  time  and again that eyewitness accounts can be
>wrong! So why would I belive that the human eye would be better than a
>computer at picking trades?
>
>H>  And IMHO you must be able to adjust your trading to fit the
>BH> environment (I am referring to intraday trading of the SP/ND/DJ in
>BH> particular)  We can have clean trends, ranges, slop and chop, etc.
>BH> The  setups,  stops  and  objectives may be determined in the same
>BH> manner,  but  how you handle the different conditions can mean the
>BH> difference between losing and winning trades/days.
>
>Anything  a  human  can  do as far as trading goes - a computer can do
>better.  The  industry  standard for discretionary vs systematic money
>managers proves that.
>
>BH> I really believe the setups, stops, etc. are fairly simple to figure
out if
>BH> you can read price.  It's the trade management that makes the
difference.
>
>if  you  only  use price as you say and not indicators then the simple
>price  over  time  calculation will run more efficiently in a computer
>than  it  ever  will  in  your  brain.  And  just  think  of all those
>psychological courses you save "not" wasting your money on.
>
>BH> Bob
>
> Mark, the mechanical trader
>
>