[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re : Systems Criteria



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links

Dans un courrier daté du 17/09/98 15:49:23  , vous avez écrit :

<< Here are good examples
 of expected figures from two different types of systems:
 
 System 1: Short - term.
 
 Win 70% or better
 Avg W/L 1.50 or better
 Profit factor : 3.0 or better
 Max DD : Less than 1/4 total net profit
 
 System 2: Long-term
 
 W % 45% or better
 Avg W/L 3.5 or better
 Profit Factor 5.0 or better
 Max DD : Less than 1/4 total net profit
 
 Regards,
 Walt Downs
 CIS Trading Cos.
  >>

I strongly disagree with these criterion.

The only intersting thing is ROMID (return on deposit +DD).
You must achieve at least a DD= 1/10 of  total net profit, 1/20 better but
more difficult over the ong run
 % of winning trades and the like are only psychological measurement.

I prefer to trade a <40% winning trade system with a low or acceptable DD and
high ROMID than anything different.
The only point that is impossible to live with is the DD.
Even if you achieve high performance on other fiels and encounter an
unexpected DD, you will stop to trade, genrally on a serious loss, even with a
70% of winning trade and  other magic ratio.
This will be the case with a 1/4 DD (DD is made to be reached some day  and of
far more).

All these consideration are coming  from real world experiences.

Sincerely,

Pierre Orphelin
www.sirtrade.com