Re: [RT] For newbies, RealTraders Email List Archive

JUST TO SAY THAT I THINK YOU'RE RIGHT, BOB, and that this

SIG group is for shared education/information and not for selling

one's experience or system.

If it were we would all drown in many other promoter's of their

systems for a fee.

Ira's comment has some merit and I'd leave it to your judgment Bob

re his offer.

----- Original Message -----

From: BobsKC

To: realtraders@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Sent: Wednesday, March 28, 2007 1:15 AM

Subject: Re: [RT] For newbies

I expected better from you Clyde. When we had a long standing rule against any advertising, you stuck your self serving web site url on all your mails and I said nothing. You made mention of your swing machine often in your posts and I said nothing. Now, you attack me because I warn people about the obvious. My motives for what I said are obvious and are not in any way self serving. The members can decide for themselves about your comments.

Bob

At 09:17 PM 3/27/2007 -0500, you wrote:

Bob,

I think your comments were ill advised.

You came late into this list and filled a void as a moderator
but in that position you should have "moderated" and not
tried to be the "godfather".

There are many of us who provide a service that is more
educational than it is monetarily rewarding.

Keep your less than well informed ideas to yourself and
let this list operate openly and without a hammer hand
expressing something that is probably not in the best
interest of the members -- particularly the "newbie" members.

I'm not sure that anyone is a "newbie" but I do know that
we have many who can well accept guidance from those of
us who have been around a long time.

If one of these "newbie's" purchases some type of a "system"
that provides them with information that leads to them finding
a method that fits their style of trading then SO BE IT AND
GOOD FOR THEM -- AND THE VENDOR.

Clyde Lee

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Clyde Lee                 phone: 713.783.9540
SYTECH Corporation
7910 Westglen, Suite 105
Houston, TX 77063     fax: 713.783.1092
WebSite:       www.theswingmachine.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

----- Original Message -----

From: BobsKC

To: realtraders@yahoogroups.com

Sent: Tuesday, March 27, 2007 08:50 PM

Subject: Re: [RT] For newbies

You fall into the possible category. You are the reason we can never say never. You are an honorable man who I would trust above nearly all others. You are the exception and there are always exceptions. But, my statements remain valid in spite of you. :))

Bob

At 03:08 PM 3/27/2007 -0700, you wrote:

I fall into the reasonable category. I retired off of the options floor in 1985. Traded up stairs and then at home. Trading is like a narcotic for me and very difficult to stop. I had a heart attach and the doctor said no more trading. Several months later someone I knew contacted me. He couldn't make a living and asked me to teach him to trade. I was reluctant to give out the system, but I said yes. To this day that party can't trade but he does write a successful news letter and does some teaching. I found that I liked teaching and have continued. The majority of people that come here do so based upon a referral from someone else who has been here. Are all the students that leave here successful? No. In any field of endeavor, is everyone who tries it successful and the answer to that is still no.   The statistics seem to indicate that 90% of new ventures fail. My success rate has been just the reverse of that.   So there are some of us who do teach for reasons other than those given in your post. I still follow the markets, I still teach a little and I post a blog on a daily basis. There is some vacation time in there also.

Ira

www.thetradersguide.net

From: BobsKC
To: realtraders@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Tuesday, March 27, 2007 1:48 PM
Subject: Re: [RT] For newbies

It's possible there could be a legitimate reason but it is also possible that someone could throw darts at a stock list and make a huge amount of money. ie: *Anything* is *possible* but the question is, how likely is it? We must all make decisions based on the probability of things and not on the possibility of things. As an advocate of methodologies, you surely would agree with this statement.

Bob

At 12:48 PM 3/27/2007 -0700, you wrote:

Bob,
Generally I agree with the content of your post, especially concerning those methods that are actively sold through mass advertising or direct mail. However, there may be legitimate reasons for making a new technology available to others. Have you ever heard of The Prediction Company? After developing a superior trading methodology based on nonlinear dynamic modeling, this group of scientists sold it to a major bank. This group had divergent interest and wished to pursue other activities. (Read "The Predictors" by Thomas Bass.) Was this a legitimate reason to sell?
Let's take another example. Active traders know that it is a time consuming and often stressful occupation. Suppose an individual developed an outstanding methodology and traded it successfully for a number of years before being advised, for health reasons, to reduce his activity. Would the desire to extract a stream of income from the methodology without the day-to- day trading activity be a legitimate reason to sell it to others?
And there is the issue of scale. Suppose the same individual above traded a six figure portfolio successfully for a number of years using a break-through technology. Then he was offered an opportunity to apply it to a hundred million dollar fund. Would it be a legitimate reason to sell?
So, perhaps you can agree that there may be legitimate reasons for making new technology available to others. As always a buyer should exercise due diligence but it is the value of the product which should be questioned - not the motivation of the seller.

Best Regards,

Jim
----- Original Message -----
From: BobsKC
To: realtraders@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Tuesday, March 27, 2007 11:18 AM
Subject: [RT] For newbies
Some time ago, I changed the rules on our list to allow advertising as long
as it didn't get out of hand and there was no pumping. I am pleased to say
that it has not gotten out of hand and has been minimal and
professional. Still, it is only a matter of common sense to think about
trading systems and stock picking systems. If the person promoting their
product really had a holy grail of trading, why would they need to sell it
to you? Put another way, if you have the combination to the safe, why sell
it to someone else? Just go in there and get all the gold you want, when
you want. Selling the combination only puts people in your line of access
and redefines how much gold there is to split since nothing is in endless
supply.
Having said that, I do not doubt the validity of those who are trying to
sell trading systems. I only doubt the need to do it if their systems work
so well. You should ask yourself these same questions before you begin
writing checks.
Hope everyone has a great trading week.
Bob