[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: GEN: Paul Merriman/ 100% Cash



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links

Since you did not answer my question:
> Have you computed his signals back to see how good he
>  is? 
I will start out by answering your statement.  I would
say 30 times going 100% cash for an advisor is not RARE.

Lets take a cursory look at his recent record.

When he was 100% cash#

# 10/27/97 S & P  877

     2/3/98 100% invested, Index 1006
	 Interim  25-75% invested
     7/9/98 100% invested   Index  1158  (close to the top)

# 8/10/98  Index  1083

     10/21  100% invested.  Index  1070
	
      1/12  100% invested.  Index  1240
	 4/26/99  100% invested.  Index 1360	 (missed the top
by 6 points)
	
       Interim  25-75% invested	

#  6/11/99 Index 1294  	

Would a buy and hold approach have produced better
results?  More later.

Norman E. 


JER3CUBE@xxxxxxx wrote:
> 
> In a message dated 6/12/99 3:19:11 PM Eastern Daylight Time,
> ericrogers@xxxxxxxxxxxxx writes:
> 
> <<
>  Have you computed his signals back to see how good he
>  is?  I question if
>  I want to take the advise of someone who shows the last
>  signal in bonds on page one of his web page as 12/1/98
>  but the last signal in his complete signal history is
>  12/31/98. He can not keep his web page straight,
>   >>
> His historical signals are available at the site(www.fundadvisor.com)
> It is RARE that any advisor would go to 100% cash.
> YOU ARE ON NOTICE ,... if you remain long or enter a trade
>         long.....in the face of warning.
> That doesn't mean you can't do it....of course you can.
> Merriman's system is largely mechanical using moving averages
> with differnet time frames.  As a trend kicks in favorable and
> and is confirmed daily, weekly, monthly, etc. a postion is increased
> or decreased.  A fourth system which he does not disclose is
> not related to moving averages.
> 
> If still wanted to trade, I would work the short side.
> The stocks I screen are showing the following possible
> canidates AA, SBC,IR, and possibly IBM
> I ALWAYS use protective stops just above the recent high
> up to two days prior.
> 
> Hope this helps.
> Tradesmart,
> GerryB/jer33:3
> eccl 1:9