[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Technical(Stock vs Commodity)



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links

My, my, I have been making money all these years on the wrong assumptions.
Guess I will have to junk my system because all those guys say it doesn't
work.  Ira

Mervin Yeung wrote:

> Hi RTs,
>
> On the subject of the difference between stock & commodity, (technical
> analysis, let me quote the interview with great traders in the book
> "Market
> Wizards":
>
> Bruce Kovner:  "The stock market has far more short-term countertrends.
> After the market has gone up, it always wants to come down.  The
> commodity markets are driven by supply and demand for physical goods; if
> there is a true shortage, prices will tend to keep trending higher.  "
>
> Richard Dennis:  "My research on individual stocks shows that price
> fluctuations are closer to random than they are in commodities.
> Demonstrably, commodities are trending and, arguably, stocks are
> random.  "
>
> Mark Weinstein:  "Absolutely.  In contrast to the commodity markets, the
> stock market very rarely gives you the opportunity to enjoy a meaningful
> trend.  ....  Because when instiutions and specialists sell out, they
> don't sell out at one price level, they scale out as the market goes
> up.  Similarly, when they buy, they scale in as the market goes down.
> This leads to choppier price action and is the reason why many good
> commodity traders that I know lose every time they go into the stock
> market.  "
>
> Good trading.
>
> Mervin