[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Cancel and Replace - a comment



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links

      All this discussion about canceling and replacing and whether to do it
or not, could be most misleading to a new  trader.   So far all that has been
discussed is whether this is wise in one situation, namely whether to replace
an existing limit order to enter at the market.   There is however another
situation.

      One is already in,  has a protective stop in place, and decides he wants
out.  Here I see there are basically 3 options:

1.  If the stop is tight and you aren't exactly sure you want out, then let
the stop do 
     its work.

2.  If the stop is tight, but you think you can get a better price at the
moment, then 
     exit, using a cancel and replace.

        These are the best two options for a new trader.

3.   If the stop has more room, then exit at the market, and then straight
cancel the       
      stop.    This is more dangerous,  for the two obvious reasons, 1. the
potential of
      the stop still getting hit, and 2.  Forgetting to cancel it.


     It is noteworthy that even if the entry order is a limit entry, one could
enter using 
     the approach in option 3,  with all its caveats.


      Point for new traders is yes clearly there is a very appropriate
situation for cancel and replace

                      Pete