[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Article on Monte Carlo Analysis of equity curves



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links

Christian writes:
  >
  > I am also constantly thinking about applying Monte-Carlo
  > simulation on a trading model which is based on a
  > portfolio of markets.  This is IMO very hard because
  > the various markets are or could be intercorrelated
  >

I wonder whether you've read the whole article
all the way to the end?  I think you may find
Section II. particularly relevant to the concern
above, especially Figures 4 through 7.  Take a
look and see what you think.
Mark,

don't wonder, I have read it till the end - more than once ;) Your made a clear conclusion in Section VII.

What I ask for is an opinion of doing that type of monte-carlo-simulation one step earlier. Imagine an extreme example where the trades are fitted (perfect example would be a over trained neural net) perfectly to the past. So doing MC on that result-set brings not much.

So the original question was and still is, if you or others see a value in testing with artificial data, be it scrambled from real data or derived with methods like Mandelbrot's. Test runs with such kind of data can be done multiple times with the same trading model.

Purpose is the same as yours - having a statistical more meaningful information about a trading model.

Christian