AW: Re[2]: OmegaList Member VK's 'Wealthlab' hits Fidelity

[<volker@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Pierre.

You left the most important comments out, the once that would be more
oriented to the ability and not to your feeling of one customer. Just in
case you have not seen them here they are again and feel free to comment:

After all if TS would have included:

Portfolio Level Backtesting
Portfolio Level Money Management
Portfolio Optimization (in one run)
Portfolio Scanning
Drag and Drop Programming
Drag and Drop of Indicators
Drag and Drop of Indicators of Indicators A huge community that has a
platform to exchange ideas Develop, Test and Scan on the web site it self

...then may be we would have never developed WLD3. This brings me back to my
earlier comments, that we are leading the way and show other products what
to include.



Volker Knapp
(www.wealth-lab.com)





***-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
***Von: Pierre Orphelin [mailto:pierre.orphelin@xxxxxxx]
***Gesendet: Monday, June 28, 2004 5:45 AM
***An: omega-list@xxxxxxxxxx
***Betreff: RE: Re[2]: OmegaList Member VK's 'Wealthlab' hits Fidelity
***
***
***
***-----Message d'origine-----
***De : volker@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:volker@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx]
***Envoyé : lundi 28 juin 2004 04:47
***Ŕ : pierre.orphelin@xxxxxxx; omega-list@xxxxxxxxxx
***Objet : AW: Re[2]: OmegaList Member VK's 'Wealthlab' hits Fidelity
***
***
***Pierre,
***
***I find your mails here regarding a user of WL rather childish. Let me sum
***up
***what you are trying to say:
***
***1. A user developed a system that you believe is impossible and he
***published
***it on a French forum.
***
***===
***I do not believe in  9 digits ROA. Do you ?
***
***
***2. He may have over optimized a whole portfolio.
***===
***Probably not
***
***
***3. He may have made an error in programming it.
***===
***Yes, or the software did it for him!
***
***Now you conclude that there is a "bug" in Wealth-Lab; that is obscene (to
***say the least).
***===
***A trading platform that allows to code  9 digits ROA from a newbie is
***BUGGED.
***You should consider to read your own forum, then you will see the
***explanation.
***
***
***If your argument is right then just think of the many system vendors that
***sell systems based on the "BOUNCING TICK" calculation of TS or the once
***that
***sell systems that are just optimized on one market.
***
***===
***With a 9 digits ROA ???????????????
***
***
***I even remember there is a guy from France that is trying to sell a fuzzy
***logic add on to TS for an outrages price, who still has not proven that
***it
***produces superior results.
***===
***Yes , because we can hardly produce  4 digits ROA.
***But they are for real.
***
***
***
***In any case, your continuous comments about ONE customer on a French
***forum
***show me that you lack further arguments which I take as a compliment.
***===
***WL does not sell a lot here.
***I have seen the same kind of error in some Metastock systems ( written by
***newbies).
***Of course, a software that allows to place a trade at the open of the
***closed bar
***is able to achieve such results.
***Anyway, I'm not interested to spend time on such discussions.
***
***
***After all if TS would have included:
***===
***9 digits ROA by drag and drop ?
***
***Sincerely,
***
***Pierre Orphelin
***www.sirtrade.com
***Tradestation 2000i, TradeStation 7 sales and support
***Safir-X, neurofuzzy logic trading system builder
***
***To subscribe to our FREE trading system newsletter:
***http://www.sirtrade.com/newsletter.htm
***<http://www.sirtrade.com/newsletter.htm>
***
***
***
***