[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re Crap Gen - Response to felixty



PureBytes Links

Trading Reference Links

Hi,

I agree that some outstanding traders (PTJ, Soros et al) make more 
'structured' traders look a bit ordinary. Just as some people possess a 
gift for varios things things such as sport, some men (eg Rupert Murdoch 
and probably many great trades) have an acute ability to sense the will 
of the people and make a ton of cash from it. 

The problem is that such unstructured methods do little to advance 
knowledge in any western empirical scientific way. Such 'feel' traders 
(particularlt Soros during the GBP play) are not readily able to 
quantify their science and learn empirically from mistakes. Had Soros 
blown up during that, what lessons could truly have been taken from that 
punt? Don't mess with a Central Bank again? 

Academics can often only try to do things in a scientific way, so that 
when things work they can be readily replicated, and when things bum 
out, it can be used as a lesson to encourage the same mistakes to be 
avoided. It all reminds me of a footer I once saw to a Professor of 
econometrics' email... 

"If we new what we were doing it wouldn't be called research"

Cheers...

   John